Best Exercise for Calorie Burn Consistency Tested
A fitness coach tested 11 exercises with three participants, finding that while walking 10,000 steps burns significant calories, more intense activities like stair climbing offer greater time efficiency for daily movement.

A small, informal test measured calorie expenditure across 10 common exercises performed by three individuals with different body types. Fitness coach Jeremy Ethier tested 11 different exercises in a YouTube video, recruiting two participants, Melody and Dennis, to test exercises with specialised equipment measuring oxygen and carbon dioxide. The three walked 10,000 steps as a baseline, which took more than 90 minutes. Ethier burned 418 calories, Melody burned 438, and Dennis burned 342 during this walk. A simple calculation suggests calories burned during 10,000 steps can be estimated by multiplying body weight in pounds by 2.7.
Key Exercise Results
Walking 10,000 steps burned between 342-438 calories while interval walking and stair climbing showed higher per-minute burn rates. The test compared this baseline to other activities completed in shorter durations. The results for each participant across the tested exercises are shown below.
| Exercise | Duration (min) | Ethier (cal) | Melody (cal) | Dennis (cal) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Japanese Interval Walking | 30 | 144 | 249 | 114 |
| Bodyweight Squats | 10 | 81 | 78 | 29 |
| Rebounding | 10 | 62 | 66 | 41 |
| Rucking (20lb vest) | 20 | 108 | 128 | 91 |
| Cycling | 20 | 130 | 119 | 88 |
| StairMaster (speed 7) | 20 | 224 | 300 | 136 |
| Sprint Intervals (incl. Afterburn) | 10 | 95 | 96 | 61 |
| Incline Walking (3mph, 9% incline) | 20 | 166 | 252 | 124 |
| Burpees | 10 | 128 | 95 | 45 |
| Vibration Plates | 10 | 28 | 22 | 33 |
Home jogging showed slightly higher heart rates than walking but similar calorie expenditure. Metronome marching burned nearly the same calories as walking, approximately matching 1,000 steps per 10 minutes. Vibration plates burned only marginally more calories than standing still.
Efficiency vs. Sustainability
The study confirms that lower-calorie exercises like bodyweight squats or rebounding may be more sustainable for long-term adherence. Jeremy Ethier stated that the best exercise is the one you can stick to, not necessarily the one that burns the most calories. "Walking 10,000 steps a day is one of the simplest ways to lose fat," Ethier said. "But there is one problem with it. Time."
More intense activities like the StairMaster or incline walking delivered higher calorie burn per minute, offering a time-efficient alternative. However, the experiment was small and informal, involving only three people, with calorie expenditure varying by body weight, fitness level, and intensity. A review in The Lancet Public Health found 7,000 steps a day were linked to a 47% lower risk of all-cause mortality versus 2,000 steps, underscoring the value of consistent, daily movement. The most effective exercise is the one maintained consistently over time.





